Even the smartest billionaires float tax schemes that punish success, ignore incentives, and expand government power instead of fixing waste. A October 29, 2026, Wall Street Journal article notes that billionaires correctly opposed California’s Proposition 40, a one-time 5 percent tax on their net worth. Yet several offered truly misguided progressive alternatives that amount to more targeted grabs on capital and property.
Here is what they propose, and why they are so far off base:
John Arnold wants long-term capital gains taxed at the same rate as ordinary income. He would adjust cost basis for inflation so only real gains are taxed. He would also tax gains when assets are gifted or transferred at death, ending the step-up in basis.
Taxing capital gains at ordinary income rates is unfair because it is a second tax on the same income. The corporation already paid tax on its earnings. When the increased value is realized by the shareholder, taxing it again at full ordinary rates is double taxation—just as dividends receive preferential rates for the same reason.
Raising the rate also increases the cost of investing and risk-taking. Capital is mobile. Higher rates reduce after-tax returns, meaning less investment, fewer startups, and slower growth. Adjusting capital gains for inflation is necessary, but it is necessary in addition to keeping the rate lower, not instead of it.
Ending the step-up in basis creates its own double taxation. An individual is already taxed at roughly 40 percent on the value of the assets left at death. Without the step-up, another capital gains tax would be due on the same assets for any gain that occurred. That is a second tax on the same asset.
Mark Cuban would force companies to give employees stock in proportion to the stock pay executives receive. He would raise the current 1 percent tax on stock buybacks. He would add an extra tax on one-time windfall profits above $1 billion from a single deal, such as the sale of a sports team.
The total amount of employee compensation is determined by economics. Employees are worth what they are worth. Forcing stock grants as part of their pay would reduce other parts of their compensation, such as cash. Employees have consistently chosen cash over other forms of compensation because cash is what they value most. Stock grants can and should be offered as an option, but they should never be forced. If an employee is willing to take stock in lieu of cash, that is fine. Forcing it is government micromanagement that pushes a less desirable form of pay on workers.
Raising the tax on buybacks is incompetent. When a company buys back its shares, it has determined it has no better internal use for the cash and is simply returning that capital to shareholders so they can put it to higher-value uses elsewhere. That improves economic efficiency. The buyback tax should be eliminated, not increased. Cuban misunderstands the economics completely. There is no logic to having a tax on it when its only effect is to make the economy more efficient.
Extra “windfall” taxes on large sales are pure confiscation. Why should gains above $1 billion—or any other arbitrary amount—be labeled a windfall? The existing capital gains tax of roughly 24 percent already applies. If that rate is reasonable for the first billion, why is it suddenly insufficient for amounts above that? Larger gains are better for the economy, not worse. Penalizing bigger successful transactions only discourages the very activity that creates jobs, investment, and growth.
Jeff Bezos would eliminate federal income tax for the bottom 50 percent of earners.
This is incredibly stupid. Skin in the game matters. People in the bottom half need to feel some cost of government so they make better voting decisions. The U.S. tax system is already more progressive than any major country’s. Removing the bottom half entirely makes it worse. Heavy progressivity pulls money out of investment and into immediate consumption. That hurts long-term growth—and ultimately hurts the very people the policy claims to help.
Bill Ackman would tax the “Buy, Borrow, Die” strategy. Under that approach, owners buy assets, borrow against the appreciation, live on the loan proceeds (which are not taxed as income), and hold until death so heirs get a stepped-up basis. Ackman would tax the portion of longer-term loans that exceeds the original cost basis of the collateral.
Ackman correctly identifies a real inefficiency in the current system. Taxing the excess loan amount is a reasonable, targeted way to address it, though the details would be complex. It is not a terrible idea.
Property belongs to the people who created or earned it. Government does not have a first claim on unrealized gains, borrowed cash, or the fruits of successful risk. Wealth taxes and their cousins punish the very capital formation that raises living standards for everyone else. Cut spending. Close real loopholes that favor special interests. Leave productive capital alone. That is the only approach consistent with growth and individual rights.



Do none of them think first of reducing spending and taxation, or do all of them think the deficit is caused by too little taxation? Sounds like they feel guilty about being rich. What a depressing thought.